Wide plank hardwood floors: Top 3 Best in 2024
Wide plank hardwood floors offer a distinctive and luxurious appearance that’s rapidly gaining popularity. But how do they compare to narrow plank hardwood floors? When choosing between wide plank and narrow plank hardwood floors, consider the following:
- Aesthetic Appeal: Wide plank floors create a spacious and modern look. Narrow plank floors offer a traditional and classic appearance.
- Durability: Wide plank floors may require more care in varying climates due to expansion and shrinkage issues.
- Cost: Wide plank floors are generally more expensive due to the higher cost of materials and installation.
- Installation: Wide plank floors require more expertise and precision to install properly.
Wide and narrow plank hardwood floors have their pros and cons. While wide planks add a dramatic and contemporary look, they can be more costly and complex to install. Narrow planks, on the other hand, bring a timeless charm and are often more budget-friendly and easier to maintain.
My name is Francisco Romero, and I have over 15 years of experience in hardwood flooring installation. At Romero Hardwood Floors Inc., I’ve dedicated myself to delivering beautiful, durable wide plank hardwood floors to countless satisfied clients.
Wide plank hardwood floors vocab explained:
– Best hardwood floor brands
– Hand-scraped hardwood floors
– Hardwood floor underlayment types
What are Wide Plank Hardwood Floors?
Wide plank hardwood floors are a type of flooring where each plank is significantly wider than traditional narrow planks. Typically, a wide plank is defined as any plank that is 5 inches or wider, with some going up to 10 inches or more.
Characteristics of Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
1. Aesthetic Appeal: Wide planks provide a bold, luxurious look that showcases the natural beauty of wood. The larger surface area allows the grain patterns and wood’s character to stand out more prominently. This creates a more dramatic and visually appealing floor.
2. Fewer Seams: With wider planks, there are fewer seams between the boards. This results in a more cohesive and seamless appearance, which many homeowners find desirable. It also means fewer places for dust and debris to accumulate, making cleaning easier.
3. Rustic and Modern Styles: Wide plank flooring can fit into various design motifs, from rustic and farmhouse styles to sleek and modern interiors. The versatility of wide planks makes them a popular choice for those looking to make a statement with their flooring.
4. Stability Considerations: While wide planks are stunning, they can be more susceptible to expansion and contraction due to changes in humidity and temperature. This can lead to cupping or gapping if not properly installed or maintained.
5. Installation Complexity: Installing wide plank floors requires a higher level of expertise. The larger size of the planks means that any imperfections in the subfloor can be more noticeable. Proper acclimation of the wood and a precise installation process are crucial to ensure the longevity and durability of the floor.
Real-World Examples
Alex E., a satisfied customer, shared, “I am just about finished remodeling my second home with wide plank floors from Romero Hardwood Floors Inc. Fabulous products – and great people to deal with.” This testimonial highlights the satisfaction and stunning results that wide plank floors can bring to a home.
Expert Insights
In older homes, wide planks were often used because fasteners were expensive and cutting wood took significant effort. Today, with advanced machining and an appreciation for the wood’s natural beauty, wide plank floors have become a modern trend. However, they are more expensive and require skilled installation.
As one Reddit expert noted, “Wider planks require more expertise when it comes down to installation. Full surface glue down is a must, because of this extra step, it is more expensive and the wood also costs more.”
Conclusion
Wide plank hardwood floors offer a unique and stunning look that can transform any space. Their ability to showcase the wood’s natural beauty and provide a seamless appearance makes them a popular choice for many homeowners. However, the increased cost and installation complexity are essential factors to consider. Whether you’re aiming for a rustic charm or a modern elegance, wide plank floors can deliver an unparalleled aesthetic appeal.
In the next section, we will dig into Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors, exploring their definition, characteristics, and how they compare to their wide plank counterparts.
What are Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors?
Narrow plank hardwood floors are a classic choice for many homeowners. They are defined by their smaller width, typically ranging from 2 to 4 inches. This traditional style of flooring has been popular for decades and continues to be a staple in many homes due to its timeless appeal and practical benefits.
Characteristics of Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
- Traditional Aesthetic: Narrow planks offer a classic look that fits well with a variety of interior designs. They are often seen in older homes and can give a space a more historical or vintage feel. The smaller width of the planks creates a more intricate and detailed floor pattern, which can be quite charming.
- Stability: One of the significant advantages of narrow planks is their stability. Because they are less susceptible to expansion and contraction due to changes in humidity and temperature, narrow planks are less likely to cup or warp. This makes them a reliable choice for areas with fluctuating climate conditions.
- Cost-Effective: Narrow plank flooring is generally more affordable than wide plank options. Not only are the materials themselves often less expensive, but the installation process is usually simpler and faster, which can reduce labor costs.
- Easier Installation: The smaller size of narrow planks makes them easier to install. They fit together more snugly and require fewer adjustments during the installation process. This can be particularly beneficial for DIY enthusiasts or those looking to save on professional installation fees.
- More Seams: While having more seams might seem like a drawback, it can actually be an advantage in some cases. The increased number of seams can help to hide imperfections in the subfloor and can also make the floor more forgiving to minor shifts and movements over time.
Real-World Examples
A user on Reddit shared their experience: “We are having white oak installed right now & the installer encouraged us to purchase 5” planks or thinner. The wider boards need extra nailing down, which adds a significant amount to the installation cost.” This highlights the practicality and cost-effectiveness of choosing narrower planks.
Another Reddit user added, “I currently have 8” wide Hickory. In the winter, I can see the subfloor. In the summer, it’s like a BMX track.” This anecdote underscores the stability benefits of narrow plank flooring, which is less prone to such extreme seasonal changes.
Expert Insights
Experts agree that narrow plank hardwood floors are a sound choice for many homeowners. As noted in the Romero Hardwood Floors installation guide, narrow boards put more fasteners per square foot, which improves their stability and adherence to the subfloor.
In summary, narrow plank hardwood floors offer a blend of traditional charm, stability, and cost-effectiveness. They are a practical choice for those looking to achieve a classic look without the higher costs and installation complexities associated with wide plank options. Whether you’re renovating an older home or simply prefer a more intricate floor pattern, narrow planks can provide the durability and aesthetic appeal you’re seeking.
Pros and Cons of Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
Advantages of Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
1. Aesthetic Appeal
Wide plank hardwood floors offer a stunning visual impact. The broader planks (typically 5 inches or wider) create a seamless, expansive look that can make any room appear larger and more open. This fewer-seams approach allows the natural beauty of the wood grain to shine through, providing a more dramatic and luxurious appearance compared to narrow planks.
2. Modern Trend
Wide plank floors are currently very “in.” Many homeowners and designers favor them for their contemporary and sophisticated look. They fit well in both modern and rustic settings, adding a touch of elegance and warmth. As one Reddit user mentioned, “Wide looks better and is more ‘in’. Older floors were narrow, so they look more dated.”
3. Fewer Seams
With fewer seams, wide plank floors offer a cleaner and more uniform appearance. This can improve the overall aesthetic of your space, creating a less busy and more cohesive look. The reduced number of seams also means fewer places for dirt and dust to accumulate, making them easier to clean and maintain.
4. Rustic Look
If you’re aiming for a rustic or farmhouse style, wide plank hardwood floors are a perfect choice. They can add a sense of history and charm to your home. The larger surface area of each plank showcases the wood’s natural knots, grains, and imperfections, giving the floor a more authentic and character-rich appearance.
Disadvantages of Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
1. Cost
Wide plank hardwood floors tend to be more expensive than their narrow counterparts. The broader the plank, the more material is used, and this often translates to higher costs. Additionally, the installation process can be more labor-intensive, further driving up expenses. As noted by a Reddit user, “The wider boards need extra nailing down, which adds a significant amount to the installation cost.”
2. Installation Complexity
Installing wide plank floors requires more expertise and precision. The larger planks can be more challenging to fit and secure properly, especially in rooms that are not perfectly square or have uneven subfloors. This complexity often necessitates professional installation, which can increase overall project costs.
3. Susceptibility to Cupping
Wide plank floors are more prone to cupping, a condition where the edges of the planks rise higher than the center. This is often caused by changes in humidity and temperature, making wide planks less stable in climates with significant seasonal variations. One Reddit user shared their experience: “I currently have 8” wide Hickory. In the winter, I can see the subfloor. In the summer, it’s like a BMX track.”
4. Climate Considerations
Due to their susceptibility to expansion and contraction, wide plank hardwood floors may not be the best choice for areas with fluctuating humidity levels. In such climates, engineered wide plank flooring might be a better option, as it’s designed to withstand these changes more effectively.
In summary, wide plank hardwood floors offer significant aesthetic advantages and are on-trend for modern interiors. However, they come with higher costs and potential installation challenges. Careful consideration of your budget, climate, and personal style preferences will help determine if wide plank floors are the right choice for your home.
Pros and Cons of Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
Advantages of Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
1. Cost-Effective
Narrow plank hardwood floors are generally more affordable than wide plank options. Because the planks are smaller, they use less raw material, which can lower the overall cost. Additionally, the installation process is often less labor-intensive and quicker, saving you money on labor costs.
2. Easier Installation
Narrow planks are easier to handle and install. They fit together more easily, especially in rooms with irregular shapes or uneven subfloors. This makes them a great option for DIY enthusiasts or for those looking to save on professional installation fees. As one Reddit user noted, “Narrow boards do put more fasteners per square foot so would adhere better.”
3. Stability
Narrow planks are less prone to issues like cupping and warping. Their smaller size makes them more stable, especially in climates with varying humidity levels. This stability ensures a longer-lasting and more durable floor. Another user shared, “The wider you go with solid flooring the more susceptible your floor will be to expansion and shrinkage.”
4. Traditional Look
If you’re aiming for a classic or traditional aesthetic, narrow plank hardwood floors are a perfect choice. They have been a staple in homes for decades and can add a timeless charm to any room. This traditional look can also increase the resale value of your home, appealing to potential buyers who appreciate classic design elements.
Disadvantages of Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
1. More Seams
Narrow planks mean more seams, which can create a busier and less uniform appearance. This can make the floor look more segmented and less cohesive. More seams also mean more places for dirt and dust to accumulate, potentially making maintenance a bit more challenging.
2. Less Modern
Narrow plank floors can sometimes look dated compared to their wide plank counterparts. While they offer a classic appeal, they may not fit well with contemporary or minimalist interior designs. As one Reddit user mentioned, “Older floors were narrow, so they look more dated.”
3. Less Dramatic Appearance
Narrow planks do not showcase the wood grain as prominently as wide planks. This can make the floor’s overall appearance less dramatic and impactful. If you’re looking for a floor that makes a bold statement, narrow planks might not deliver the visual impact you desire.
In summary, narrow plank hardwood floors offer several practical advantages, including cost-effectiveness, easier installation, and greater stability. However, they come with aesthetic trade-offs, such as more seams and a less modern look. Your choice will depend on your budget, installation preferences, and the overall style you want to achieve in your home.
Cost Comparison: Wide Plank vs. Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
When choosing between wide plank hardwood floors and narrow plank hardwood floors, cost is a significant factor to consider. Let’s break down the price range and cost factors for both options to help you make an informed decision.
Price Range
Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
– Material Cost: Wide plank hardwood floors typically range from $8 to $25 per square foot. This higher cost is due to the larger size of each plank, which uses more raw material.
– Installation Cost: Installation costs for wide plank floors can range from $3 to $10 per square foot. The larger size of the planks can make the installation process more labor-intensive, which can increase the cost.
– Total Cost: On average, expect to pay between $11 and $35 per square foot for wide plank hardwood floors, including both material and installation.
Narrow Plank Hardwood Floors
– Material Cost: Narrow plank hardwood floors are generally less expensive, ranging from $3 to $15 per square foot. The smaller size of the planks reduces material costs.
– Installation Cost: Installation costs for narrow plank floors typically range from $3 to $8 per square foot. The smaller planks are easier to handle and install, which can lower labor costs.
– Total Cost: On average, expect to pay between $6 and $23 per square foot for narrow plank hardwood floors, including both material and installation.
Cost Factors
Material Quality: The type of wood and its quality significantly impact the cost. For example, exotic woods like Brazilian cherry will be more expensive than domestic woods like oak or maple.
Plank Width: As mentioned, wider planks are generally more expensive due to the increased amount of raw material required. However, the installation of wider planks can sometimes be quicker, potentially reducing labor costs.
Installation Complexity: Wide plank floors often require glue-assisted installation and extra nailing, which can increase labor costs. Narrow planks are easier to install, especially in rooms with irregular shapes or uneven subfloors.
Climate Considerations: Wide plank floors are more susceptible to expansion and shrinkage due to changes in humidity. This means they may require additional treatments or installation techniques to ensure stability, which can add to the overall cost.
Aesthetic Preferences: If you’re aiming for a modern or rustic look, wide plank floors are often preferred despite their higher cost. Narrow planks offer a more traditional appearance, which might be more suitable for certain home styles and budgets.
In summary, wide plank hardwood floors tend to be more expensive due to their material and installation costs, but they offer a dramatic and modern aesthetic. Narrow plank hardwood floors are more cost-effective and easier to install, providing a traditional look. Your choice will depend on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and installation considerations.
Installation Considerations
When it comes to installing wide plank hardwood floors versus narrow plank hardwood floors, there are several factors to consider. Each type has unique installation requirements, skill levels, and cost implications.
Wide Plank Installation
Installation Process: Wide plank hardwood floors often require a more complex installation process. Due to the larger size of the planks, extra steps like glue-assisted installation and additional nailing are usually necessary to ensure stability. This involves applying a bead of glue to the subfloor before placing the planks and then nailing them down to secure them further.
Skill Level: Installing wide plank floors typically requires a higher level of expertise. The larger planks can be more challenging to handle and align correctly, especially in rooms with irregular shapes or uneven subfloors. Professional installers with experience in wide plank flooring are usually recommended for this type of job.
Cost Implications: The complexity of the installation process for wide plank floors can drive up labor costs. The need for additional materials like glue and the extra time required for proper installation contribute to the higher overall cost. While the material cost for wide planks ranges from $8 to $25 per square foot, installation costs can add another $3 to $10 per square foot.
Narrow Plank Installation
Installation Process: Narrow plank hardwood floors are generally easier to install. The smaller size of the planks makes them easier to handle, cut, and fit into various room shapes. This type of flooring typically uses a staple or nail-down installation method, which is less labor-intensive compared to wide planks.
Skill Level: The installation of narrow plank floors can often be handled by less experienced installers or even DIY enthusiasts. The straightforward nature of the installation process makes it a more accessible option for those looking to save on labor costs.
Cost Implications: Narrow plank floors are more cost-effective in terms of both materials and installation. The material cost ranges from $3 to $15 per square foot, and installation costs are typically between $3 to $8 per square foot. The ease of installation reduces labor time and costs, making it a budget-friendly option.
In summary, while wide plank hardwood floors offer a dramatic and modern look, they require a more complex and costly installation process. Narrow plank hardwood floors are easier and cheaper to install, making them a practical choice for those looking to save on costs without compromising on style.
Style and Aesthetic Appeal
When choosing between wide plank hardwood floors and narrow plank hardwood floors, style and aesthetic appeal are crucial factors. Each type brings its own unique charm and visual impact to a space.
Wide Plank Style
Wide plank hardwood floors are known for their bold and dramatic look. With fewer seams, these floors create a more continuous and expansive appearance, making rooms feel larger and more open. This style is particularly popular in modern and rustic design trends, where the natural beauty of the wood can take center stage.
- Rustic Charm: Wide planks often showcase the wood’s natural knots, grain patterns, and imperfections, giving a rustic and authentic feel. This makes them a great choice for farmhouse or vintage-inspired interiors.
- Modern Elegance: In contemporary settings, wide planks add a sleek and sophisticated touch. They work well with minimalist designs, where the simplicity and clean lines of the wide boards complement the overall aesthetic.
- Fewer Seams: With fewer seams, wide plank floors have a more uniform and less busy appearance. This can make the space look more cohesive and streamlined.
Narrow Plank Style
Narrow plank hardwood floors offer a more traditional and classic look. They are characterized by more seams, which can create a visually intricate pattern that adds texture and interest to the floor.
- Traditional Appeal: Narrow planks are often associated with classic and historical homes. Their timeless look fits well with traditional and transitional design styles, adding a touch of elegance and refinement.
- Subtle Look: The numerous seams in narrow plank floors create a more detailed and patterned appearance. This can make the floor a focal point without overwhelming the space, ideal for rooms with intricate decor or furnishings.
- Versatility: Narrow planks are versatile and can complement a wide range of interior styles, from cozy cottages to formal dining rooms.
In summary, wide plank hardwood floors are perfect for those seeking a modern, dramatic, and expansive look, while narrow plank hardwood floors offer a classic, detailed, and versatile appearance. The choice between the two ultimately depends on your personal style and the overall aesthetic you wish to achieve in your home.
Durability and Maintenance
Wide Plank Durability
Wide plank hardwood floors are stunning, but their durability can vary based on several factors.
Stability: One of the key concerns with wide planks is stability. Due to their size, wide planks are more susceptible to expansion and contraction with changes in humidity. In climates with significant seasonal changes, this can lead to issues like cupping or warping. To combat this, it’s often recommended to use engineered wide planks, which have a more stable core than solid wood.
Climate Impact: Wide plank floors can be more sensitive to moisture. As one user on Reddit mentioned, “In the winter, I can see the subfloor. In the summer, it’s like a BMX track.” This highlights the importance of maintaining a consistent indoor climate to minimize movement in the wood.
Maintenance Tips:
– Regular Cleaning: Keep your wide plank floors clean by sweeping or vacuuming regularly to remove dirt and debris that can cause scratches.
– Humidity Control: Use a humidifier in the winter and a dehumidifier in the summer to maintain consistent indoor humidity levels.
– Protective Measures: Place mats at entryways to reduce dirt and grit, and use felt pads under furniture legs to prevent scratches.
Narrow Plank Durability
Narrow plank hardwood floors are generally more stable and easier to maintain.
Stability: Narrow planks have more seams and fasteners per square foot, which improves their stability. This makes them less prone to the expansion and contraction issues that can affect wide planks. As a result, they tend to handle changes in humidity better, making them a solid choice for areas with fluctuating climates.
Maintenance Tips:
– Regular Cleaning: Similar to wide planks, regular sweeping or vacuuming will help keep your floors in good shape.
– Preventative Care: Use rugs and mats in high-traffic areas to protect the floor from wear and tear. Also, trim pet nails to avoid scratches.
– Refinishing: Narrow planks can be refinished multiple times, extending their lifespan and keeping them looking new. This is especially advantageous since any damage or wear can be sanded away and refinished.
Longevity: With proper care, narrow plank hardwood floors can last for decades. Their ability to be refinished multiple times adds to their longevity, making them a durable and long-lasting flooring option.
In summary, wide plank hardwood floors require more climate control and careful maintenance to prevent issues like cupping, while narrow plank hardwood floors offer greater stability and are easier to maintain. Both options can be durable and beautiful with the right care, so your choice should depend on your specific needs and environment.
Frequently Asked Questions about Wide Plank Hardwood Floors
Is wide plank hardwood more expensive?
Yes, wide plank hardwood floors generally come with a higher price tag compared to narrow planks. The reasons for this are multifaceted:
- Material Cost: Wide planks require larger cuts of wood, which are less common and more expensive to produce.
- Installation: Installing wide planks can be more labor-intensive, requiring extra nailing and glue assistance. This increases both labor and material costs. As noted on Reddit, “The wider boards need extra nailing down, which adds a significant amount to the installation cost.”
Despite the higher cost, many find the aesthetic appeal of wide planks worth the investment.
What is the best hardwood floor plank width?
The “best” plank width depends on your personal style preferences and the specific needs of your space:
- Wide Planks (5 inches and above): These offer a modern, spacious look with fewer seams, making them ideal for larger rooms or open floor plans. However, they are more susceptible to expansion and contraction due to humidity changes.
- Narrow Planks (2-3 inches): These provide a traditional, classic appearance and are more stable in varying climates. They are also easier to install and maintain.
A user on Reddit mentioned, “Install what you like but follow the mfg’s instructions for the flooring you choose.” This underscores the importance of considering both aesthetic and practical factors when choosing plank width.
Is wide plank flooring still in style?
Absolutely, wide plank hardwood floors are very much in style and have been growing in popularity. They offer a rustic, yet sophisticated look that appeals to many homeowners. As discussed in the Gaylord Hardwood Flooring blog, wide planks are considered more “in” at the moment.
However, trends can change, so choose a style that you love and that fits well with your home’s overall decor. Wide planks offer a timeless appeal that can adapt to various interior design styles, from modern to rustic.
Conclusion
Choosing between wide plank and narrow plank hardwood floors depends on your personal preferences, budget, and the specific needs of your space. Both options have their unique advantages and potential drawbacks.
Wide plank hardwood floors offer a modern, spacious look with fewer seams, making them ideal for larger rooms or open floor plans. They are highly durable and can add significant value to your home. However, they are more susceptible to expansion and contraction due to humidity changes and can be more expensive to install.
Narrow plank hardwood floors provide a traditional, classic appearance and are more stable in varying climates. They are generally easier to install and maintain, making them a cost-effective choice for many homeowners. However, they may not offer the same dramatic visual impact as wide planks.
At Romero Hardwood Floors Inc, we specialize in helping you find the perfect flooring solution for your home. Our team of experts is dedicated to providing high-quality installations that improve the beauty and functionality of your space.
Whether you prefer the rustic charm of wide planks or the timeless elegance of narrow planks, we are here to guide you through the entire process, ensuring you make an informed decision that you’ll love for years to come.
Thank you for considering Romero Hardwood Floors Inc for your hardwood flooring needs. We look forward to helping you create a beautiful and lasting foundation in your home.
